I think I have high taste and or standards?

I've always, really like natural beauties like Charlize Therone who look amazing even without makeup(perfer no makeup). On the other hand, I find myself contradicting myself and really noticing high matienence girls who wear too much lip gloss, have thick Kardashian hair,bags and oversized sunglasses. However, that being said, what makes my heart go pitter, patter is a sweet, nurturing, affectionate girl especially they're open about their feelings. Can I find a Charlize Therone 'natural' beauty or a Mary Kate ish hipster/oversized sunglasses chick with a wonderful heart? If so, what do they expect from their potential girlfriends? i.e. physical attractions? or should I really lower my standards and be more realistic? since I don't have any chance in hell to ever date them.